Cloaked vs IDX: Privacy and Identity Protection Comparison

January 15, 2025
·
3 min
deleteme

Protect yourself from future breaches

Feature Cloaked IDX
Identify exposed data
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Remove exposed data
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Prevent data theft
Yes Yes
No No
Privacy Insurance
Yes Yes
Yes Yes

Introduction

With the rise of online threats, choosing the right privacy and identity protection service is critical. Cloaked and IDX are two leading solutions that cater to different aspects of privacy protection. While Cloaked emphasizes data masking, identity theft prevention, and aliases, IDX offers a mix of identity monitoring, credit protection, and data removal services.

This comparison examines Cloaked and IDX in terms of features, pricing, pros and cons, and the best use cases to help you find the solution that best fits your needs.

Product Overview

Cloaked

Cloaked is an all-encompassing privacy tool designed to provide comprehensive protection for your personal information.

Key Features:

  • Email and phone number aliases: Mask your real contact details during communication.
  • Masked payments: Beta feature that hides payment details during transactions.
  • Identity theft insurance: $1 million per user.
  • Risk scans: Free and comprehensive.
  • Password management: Securely store and manage passwords.

Upcoming Features:

  • VPN: for safe browsing.
  • AI Defense: for advanced threat detection.
  • Cloaked Pay: for enhanced masked payment solutions.
  • Email Cleaner: Advanced email cleaner for sorting out inbox.

IDX

IDX specializes in identity protection, offering a mix of identity monitoring, credit monitoring, and data removal services.

Key Features by Plan:

  • IDX Identity: Focused on identity monitoring, identity theft insurance, and social media monitoring.
  • IDX Privacy: Data removal (ForgetMe), password management, and VPN.
  • IDX Complete: Combines identity monitoring and privacy protection with credit monitoring, password management, and VPN.

Feature Comparison

Feature Cloaked IDX
Pricing Starting at $8.00/Month Starting at $8.96/Month
Email Aliases
Yes Yes
No No
Phone Number Aliases
Yes Yes + eSIMs
No No
Masked Payment Method
Yes Yes (Beta)
No No
Password Management
Yes Yes
Yes (Complete and Privacy plans)
Data Removal
Yes Yes
Yes (Privacy and Complete plans)
Identity Theft Insurance $1 Million per user Up to $1 Million
Risk Scan Most comprehensive + free
No No
Malware/Spam Detection
No No
No No
Identity Monitoring
No No
Yes (Identity and Complete plans)
VPN Upcoming Yes (Complete and Privacy plans)

Key Takeaways:

       1. Cloaked offers unique privacy features such as email aliases, phone number masking, and masked payments, which are unavailable in IDX plans.

       2. IDX only focuses on identity monitoring and credit protection, making it more suitable for users focused on credit security.

       3. Cloaked’s upcoming VPN and AI Defense expand its scope.

Pricing Comparison

Cloaked Pricing

Plan Monthly Price Annual Price Features
Individual $9.99 $8.00/month ($95.99 annually) Privacy tools, $1 million identity theft insurance, aliases, and password management.
Couple $15.99 $5.83/member/month ($139.99 annually) Protection for two users, each with $1 million insurance.
Family $23.99 $5.00/member/month ($239.99 annually) Protection for up to four members, each with $1 million insurance.

IDX Pricing

Plan Monthly Price Annual Price Features
IDX Identity (Individual) $9 $8.96/month ($107.52 annually) Identity monitoring, $1 million insurance, and social media monitoring.
IDX Identity (Family) $19 $17/month ($204 annually) Same as individual, for up to 5 members.
IDX Complete (Individual) $32 $29.61/month ($355.32 annually) All IDX Identity features plus credit monitoring, VPN, and private search.
IDX Privacy (Individual) $12 $11.66/month ($139.92 annually) Data removal, password management, VPN, and private browsing.

Pricing Insights:

  • Cloaked’s Individual plan ($9.99/month) is comparable to IDX Identity ($9/month) but offers more privacy features, including aliases and masked payments.
  • IDX Complete is significantly more expensive ($32/month) but includes credit monitoring, VPN, and private browsing.
  • Cloaked’s family plan is more cost-effective than IDX’s family options, offering better value for households.

Pros and Cons

Cloaked

Pros:

  • Offers unique privacy tools like aliases and masked payments.
  • Identity theft insurance included in all plans.
  • Affordable family and couple plans.
  • Free and comprehensive risk scans.
  • Upcoming features like VPN, Email Cleaner and AI Defense for added value.

Cons:

  • Lacks identity monitoring and credit-related features.

IDX

Pros:

  • Strong identity monitoring features with credit monitoring (Complete plan).
  • Integration of VPN and private browsing tools.
  • Flexible family coverage for up to five minors.

Cons:

  • No privacy tools like aliases or masked payments.
  • High costs for premium plans like IDX Complete.
  • Risk scans and free-tier options are not available.

Best Use Cases

Cloaked is Best For:

  • Individuals and families seeking comprehensive privacy tools like aliases and masked payments.
  • Users who prioritize affordability and protection against identity theft.
  • Those looking for a forward-thinking privacy solution with upcoming features like a VPN and AI Defense.

IDX is Best For:

  • Users focused on identity and credit monitoring.

Conclusion

Cloaked is the better choice for users who want a privacy-focused solution with tools like aliases, masked payments, and identity theft insurance, all at an affordable price. Its upcoming features further enhance its value for long-term use.

IDX, on the other hand, only focuses on identity and credit monitoring, making it useful for users who prioritize financial security and detailed credit insights. However, its premium plans come at a higher cost, and offer way less features.

For most users, especially those seeking versatile and affordable privacy protection, Cloaked provides greater value and a more comprehensive feature set.

Explore Cloaked’s plans here to secure your digital privacy today!

Glossary of Terms

       1. Email Aliases: Temporary email addresses that forward messages to your inbox, protecting your primary email.

       2. Masked Payment Method: Virtual payment cards that protect your real financial information during transactions.

       3. Data Removal: Process of requesting the deletion of personal information from online data brokers.

       4. Identity Monitoring: Alerts for suspicious activity involving your personal information, such as breaches or misuse.

       5. Risk Scan: A comprehensive analysis of vulnerabilities related to your online data.

       6. VPN (Virtual Private Network): Encrypts internet traffic, ensuring safe and private online activity.

       7. Credit Monitoring: Tracks changes to your credit report and alerts you to potential fraud.

       8. Social Media Monitoring: Scans your social media for signs of privacy risks or misuse.

Protect yourself from future breaches

View all
Company Updates
January 17, 2025

Cloaked vs Mozilla Monitor: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

Cloaked vs Mozilla Monitor: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

by
Pulkit Gupta
Company Updates
January 17, 2025

Cloaked vs Mozilla Monitor: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

Cloaked vs Mozilla Monitor: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

by
Pulkit Gupta
Company Updates
January 13, 2025

Cloaked vs Kanary: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

Cloaked vs Kanary: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

by
Pulkit Gupta
Company Updates
January 13, 2025

Cloaked vs Kanary: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

Cloaked vs Kanary: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

by
Pulkit Gupta
Company Updates
January 11, 2025

Cloaked vs Privacy Bee: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

Cloaked vs Privacy Bee: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

by
Pulkit Gupta
Company Updates
January 11, 2025

Cloaked vs Privacy Bee: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

Cloaked vs Privacy Bee: Privacy and Data Protection Comparison

by
Pulkit Gupta